Archive for Proposed Demolitions

2741 Bienville in Mid City - A modified single shotgun house

The owners of the following properties were denied permission to demolish these properties by the Neighborhood Conservation District Committee and have chosen to appeal (property owners reserve the right to appeal decisions of the NCDC to the City Council).

These properties will be reviewed this Thursday, September 2nd:

1541 Mazant (NCDC Appeal, on deadline) Cn. Palmer’s district

2760-62 Conti (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district

2741 Bienville (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district

318 N. White (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district

This is your opportunity to submit written comment to City Council.
Follow the links above to send an email to the Councilmember in which these properties are located.
Comments (0)
Aug
31

Carver School To Be Demolished

Posted by: LDerrington | Comments (0)

Carver Junior-Senior High, 3059 Higgins Blvd

Of New Orleans’ three Modern schools eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, only George Washington Carver Junior-Senior High in the Ninth Ward will be demolished without the benefit of the standard federally mandated historic preservation consultation process (Section 106 review). Unlike Lafon and Wheatley schools, decisions concerning Carver’s fate were streamlined through a Secondary Programmatic Agreement between FEMA and the Recovery School District (RSD). Under this, the district recommended demolition and FEMA and the SHPO agreed with minimal feedback from outside parties. While it is neither reasonable nor feasible to put every historic structure through the full consultation process, it is sad indeed that buildings as important as those on the Carver campus will be lost with so little public input.

Designed by Curtis & Davis and completed in 1958, Carver was part of the $30 million building program which gave New Orleans its outstanding collection of modern schools. The program, headed by a progressive Orleans Parish School Board and Tulane School of Architecture’s Charles Colbert, had been launched five years earlier in response to antiquated conditions found throughout the district after World War II.

Carver Auditorium, Buttresses

Curtis & Davis had recently completed their award-winning Thomy Lafon Elementary when they won the commission for the $3 million Carver complex. Their cruciform design consisted of a central raised classroom building flanked by wings to the east and west, connected by walkways to a gymnasium and cafeteria to the north and auditorium to the south. The auditorium was the campus’ stylistic jewel, with dramatic hinged concrete buttresses anchoring its vaulted roof. Carver received Progressive Architecture’s highest honor, the First Design Award, in 1957, and was hailed one of the most forward-thinking school designs in the nation.

While most of Carver’s buildings have been seriously altered over the years, both the auditorium and butterfly-roofed cafeteria retain their architectural integrity despite flooding after Hurricane Katrina. The auditorium in particular is in excellent condition, and could easily be incorporated into designs for the new school intended for the thirty-three acre site.

Carver School, Cafeteria Building

As the story goes though, the RSD has no interest in retaining either building. Its representatives blame bat and rat infestations on the auditorium’s design – which could instead have something to do with the fact that the building is open to the elements – and state that both structures are functionally obsolete. Citing similarities between the buttresses Curtis & Davis used at Carver and those they used for the Louisiana State Penitentiary cafeteria, the RSD believes that children would relate their school to a prison if the auditorium were preserved. This argument is somewhat hard to swallow, since buildings of similar eras tend to share similar elements; it is a little like insisting that schools featuring Classical Revival or Art Deco elements should be razed because of their similarities to the Criminal Courts Building in front of Orleans Parish Prison.

Carver Auditorium, Interior

Rebuilding Carver is slated for the first phase of the school district’s rebuilding program, and the January 2010 RSD Capital Update states that demolition will begin December of this year. The RSD will be required to document and memorialize the historic buildings on-site, but they will be demolished nonetheless. Breathtaking in its monumentality, the auditorium is one of the most important modern structures in New Orleans.

New Orleans' African-American leaders chalked up another victory when the much lobbied for Booker T. Washington High School, with its emphasis upon vocational training, opened in 1942. But it took federal funds to make it happen.

Meeting to discuss Booker T. Washington School Building
Thursday, August 26, 2010
6:30 PM
Sylvanie F. Williams School Cafeteria
3127 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd.

The opening of Booker T. (as it is affectionately known) in September 1942 was a cause for great rejoicing in New Orleans’ large African-American population. After all, in 1900 the New Orleans School Board had voted to limit black education to the first five grades. Now a splendid new high school was opening that rivaled any white school—not a hand-me-down school but a state-of-the-art facility built specifically for black secondary education—a first in the city.

How had it all happened? Through decades of sustained activism from black leaders and bailout from the federal government.

Lacking political power, black leaders worked through civic, religious and educational organizations to press their concerns before the school board, being first with the total lack of public education beyond the fifth grade, as mandated by school board policy in 1900. The sixth was restored in 1909, the seventh in 1913, and the eighth in 1914. With these milestones under their belts, black leaders began the campaign for a high school. The much sought after school opened in 1917 as McDonogh No. 35 in a recycled former school for whites.

The next item on the activist agenda was a sorely needed vocational school. But where to find the money? The Rosenwald Fund had expressed an interest but only if the school board shared the cost. In 1930 the school board sold bonds for school construction and allocated $275,000 toward construction of a black trade school. The Rosenwald Fund pledged $135,000.

In response to concerns that a black trade school might threaten white jobs, a public statement was issued, assuring everyone “that the trades to be taught at the school would be exclusively those which are largely occupied by colored labor at this time.”

But it would still be another dozen years before Booker T. became a reality. After purchasing a parcel of land for the purpose, the school board announced that it did not have the money to match the Rosenwald offer. Instead, in 1934 they built on the site a wood frame elementary school for blacks for $21,000.

Although disheartened by this broken promise, black leaders continued to champion their goal through the 1930s. But it was federal, not local funds, which made Booker T. possible.

Booker T. Washington's cavernous auditorium was used for much more than school functions. It became in effect the city's black municipal auditorium, housing legendary entertainers like Louis Armstrong, labor rallies, conventions and the like.

In the twilight of its existence, the New Deal’s Works Progress Administration funded the project to the tune of some quarter of a million dollars. Like other similar schools across the South, it was named for booker T. Washington, the famous black educator whose name is synonymous with what was called at the time “industrial education.”

But the opening of Booker T. gave the African-American community much more than a new high school. Accompanying the school (and attached to it) was a huge auditorium that became in effect the city’s black municipal auditorium. In the age of segregation, the roughly 2,000 capacity auditorium was indeed “separate but equal.” Soon after its opening, the facility hosted Paul Robeson in his first New Orleans appearance. The Louisiana Weekly reported that blacks turned out “en masse” to hear Robeson, although with “a fair sprinkling whites.” There were seven encores, and the audience was “almost shaking the roof with its thunderous applause.”

Other greats who graced the stage include Marian Anderson, Dizzie Gillespie, Mahalia Jackson and Louis Armstrong.

Booker T’s immense importance made it a natural for the National Register of Historic Places. The project was undertaken by the Division of Historic Preservation at the request of Booker T. teacher Mark Wuirk. The black leaders who pushed so hard for its construction would have been thrilled at the delegation of Booker T. graduates who attended the public hearing in Baton Rouge. In testimony after testimony folks spoke passionately about all Booker T. had given to them—from discipline to Bach, and everything in between. On Saturday, September 7, 2002, they celebrated the 60th anniversary of the school and the listing with a historic marker dedication at1201 S. Roman Street.

Written by PRC board member Donna Fricker for Preservation in Print, September 2002

1541-43 Mazant, Bunny Friend

The owners of the following properties were denied permission to demolish these properties by Historic District Landmarks Commission or the Neighborhood Conservation District Committee and have chosen to appeal (property owners reserve the right to appeal decisions of the HDLC and NCDC to the City Council).

These properties will be reviewed this Thursday, August 26th:

2535 Esplanade (Partial Demolition, HDLC Appeal) Cn. Guidry’s district
1541 Mazant (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Palmer’s district
2760-62 Conti (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district

The hearing date for these properties has been set for next Thursday, September 2nd:

2741 Bienville (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district
318 N. White (NCDC Appeal) Cn. Head’s district

This is your opportunity to submit written comment to City Council.
Follow the links above to send an email to the Councilmember in which these properties are located.
Comments (0)

2760 Conti St. in Mid City

The owners of the following properties were denied permission to demolish these properties by Historic District Landmarks Commission or the Neighborhood Conservation District Committee. They have chosen to appeal and the hearing date has been set for August 26, 2010. (Property owners reserve the right to appeal decisions of the HDLC and NCDC to the City Council.)

2535 Esplanade (Partial Demolition, HDLC Appeal) Cm. Guidry’s district

1541 Mazant (NCDC Appeal) Cm. Palmer’s district
2760-62 Conti (NCDC Appeal) Cm. Head’s district
·
·
This is your opportunity to submit written comment to City Council.
Follow the links above to send an email to the Councilmember in which these properties are located.
Comments (0)

Though Monday’s Neighborhood Conservation District Committee agenda was unusually (and blissfully) short, all three demolitions were approved. To see the properties, click here.

2921 Live Oak, Holly Grove: Demolition Approved

Comments (0)
NEIGHBORHOOD CONSERVATION DISTRICT COMMITTEE AGENDA.

2815 Second Street, Central City National Historic District

 Only three properties are up for demolition! Click here for the agenda.

Comments (0)

To view the results from the NCDC meeting, click here.


5200 St. Claude - Demolition Denied


4307 S. Miro - Demolition Denied

Comments (0)

5200 St. Claude Ave. in Holy Cross (Before Renovation)

5200 St. Claude Ave. in Holy Cross (After Renovation)

Click here to view the complete NCDC agenda.

This modified four-bay Creole cottage, located at 5200 St. Claude Ave. in Holy Cross, is likely one of the oldest structures in the Lower 9th Ward. Creole cottages of this type were constructed primarily between 1709 and 1850. It appears on the Robinson Atlas of 1883 and in the 1908-09 Sanborne map. This structure clearly illustrates the character of the neighborhood has served the needs of the neighborhood as a long-established corner store.

The Board of Zoning Adjustments considered the redevelopment plans for the site on June 14, 2010 and the application was withdrawn without prejudice, meaning that the owner can again try to seek approval. Further, the City Council recently rejected the owner’s request for an alcoholic beverage outlet on the site. The Neighborhood Conservation District Review Committee will consider the proposed demolition on August 2, 2010. Watch this site for the results.

Click here to view the complete NCDC agenda.

Learn about two-bay Creole cottages here.

Comments (0)

The request to demolish 318 N. White St. was denied by the NCDC.

Click here for the results.

Comments (0)
Our mission: to promote the preservation, restoration and revitalization of the historic neighborhoods and architecture of New Orleans.